Elevated view across a quiet November garden toward a substantial cedar-shingled village house with white-trimmed dormers.

How 'Sconset Homes Sold Against Their Assessed Values This Fall

Cottage Avenue is a short lane in the 'Sconset village core, and two of its houses sold within a month of each other this fall. 17 Cottage Avenue, on .12 acres, went for $2,440,000 in the transfers Nantucket Current reported for October 1 to 8, 2026. The town assessed it at $1,619,100. A few weeks later, 12 Cottage Avenue went for $4,200,000 on .11 acres. It is known on the lane as "Grand Central," and its assessment was $2,241,500. The first sold 51% above the town's figure and the second 87% above.

Those two sales are typical of this fall's village trades. They show what you are paying for in 'Sconset, and the assessment on a listing doesn't capture most of it.

The town's number reflects the market of January 2025

You'll see an assessed value next to most Nantucket sales, and it comes with a date. The Town of Nantucket's online property database says its posted Fiscal Year 2026 values "are based on market value as of January 1, 2025, using sales data from calendar year 2024."

That means every fall 2026 sale is being measured against a model built on sales from two years earlier. You'd expect most of them to sell above it. The gap at any one address tells you little, because every house carries the same lag. The useful information comes from comparing houses with each other, and in 'Sconset this fall the houses that sold far above their assessments and the ones that sold near them followed a clear pattern.

Eleven fall sales against the assessment

These are the 'Sconset sales Nantucket Current listed in its weekly roundups for transfers recorded from September 10 through November 5, 2026. Each is shown with the town's assessed value as the roundup gave it. The ratio is the sale price divided by the assessment.

Address Setting Lot Sale price Assessed value Price vs. assessment
12 Cottage Avenue Village core .11 ac $4,200,000 $2,241,500 87% above
10 Center Street Village core .03 ac $2,500,000 $1,514,700 65% above
17 Cottage Avenue Village core .12 ac $2,440,000 $1,619,100 51% above
3 West Sankaty Road Village core .13 ac $4,400,000 $2,924,300 50% above
20 Shell Street Village core .07 ac $2,625,000 $1,889,000 39% above
9 Park Lane Village core .02 ac $1,195,000 $1,297,317 8% below
46 Baxter Road Anne's Lane .27 ac $5,500,000 $4,298,600 28% above
76 Sankaty Road Toward Sankaty Head .18 ac $3,450,000 $2,947,100 17% above
318 Milestone Road Half mile from the village .46 ac $4,875,000 $4,981,300 2% below
3 Manatook Way Near the village .51 ac $8,625,000 $2,808,500 about 3 times
100 Baxter Road Just outside the village .48 ac $1,100,000 $1,660,823 34% below

Eleven sales over eight weeks is a sample, not a market census, and the ratios are rounded. The pattern still holds across them. Five of the six village-core houses sold 39% to 87% above their assessments. Once you leave the core for Sankaty Road, Baxter Road and Milestone Road, the gap gets smaller. Three sales came in under assessment. One was the smallest house in the group and one was the house farthest out. The third, 100 Baxter Road, was a two-story building the listing described as a garage and gym with a one-bedroom living space above, which is a different kind of property from a finished house.

Inside the village, full houses went 39% to 87% above

Lot size had little to do with it. 10 Center Street is a .03-acre lot. It sold for $2,500,000, 65% above its $1,514,700 assessment, in transfers recorded September 17 to 24. 20 Shell Street is a .07-acre lot and sold for $2,625,000 against a $1,889,000 assessment. Both lots are smaller than many backyards elsewhere on the island, and both sold far above what the 2024-based model expected.

What those buyers paid for shows up in the listing language the Current reprinted. 3 West Sankaty Road sold for $4,400,000 on .13 acres, 50% above assessment. According to the listing in the Nantucket Current roundup for October 1, it had three finished levels and sat "an eight-minute stroll from 'Sconset Beach, the iconic 'Sconset Bluff Walk, 'Sconset Market, local cafés and restaurants, the neighborhood playground, and the Siasconset Casino tennis club." The 12 Cottage Avenue description pointed to the village center, the beach stairs, air conditioning and a garage, which is rare on a lane that size.

A mass-appraisal model can account for square footage and lot size. It has a harder time pricing an address where the market, the Casino and the beach stairs are all a short walk away, and in 'Sconset that is the scarce thing. The core is small and fully built, so supply only grows when a house in it comes up for sale.

The Telegraph House sold under its assessment

9 Park Lane is the exception inside the village. In transfers recorded October 22 to 29, 2026, the one-bedroom cottage on .02 acres sold for $1,195,000 against an assessment of $1,297,317, roughly 8% below. The listing, reprinted by Nantucket Current, called it "Telegraph House." It was built in 1924 as the place summer visitors went to reach the mainland, and it later housed a tea room, a yarn shop and a record store.

It is as central as any house on the list, a short walk from the 'Sconset Market and the Casino. So the village premium isn't paid on location alone. In this fall's sales it went to houses big enough for a family's summer, and a one-bedroom cottage with real history sold close to the town's number. If you're weighing a very small village cottage, you're paying for a different product from the multi-level houses around it, and this fall it was priced that way.

Past the village core, the gap narrows

Along Sankaty Road and Baxter Road, houses still sold above assessment, but by less. 76 Sankaty Road, called "Blue Whale," sits by the bike path roughly halfway between Sankaty Head Lighthouse and the village. It sold for $3,450,000, 17% above its $2,947,100 assessment, in transfers recorded October 1 to 8. 46 Baxter Road, called "Family Matters," is on Anne's Lane and has five bedrooms, a wraparound porch and a widow's walk. It sold for $5,500,000, 28% above its $4,298,600 assessment, in transfers recorded October 15 to 22. Earlier in the year, 44 Sankaty Road sold for $4,212,500 against a $3,546,100 assessment in transfers recorded June 4 to 11, about 19% above and in the same range.

318 Milestone Road, half a mile out, sold almost exactly at its assessment. It is a custom contemporary on .46 acres that backs onto Sconset Land Trust land, and its listing, reprinted in the Nantucket Current roundup for November 5, described its sunset views as "protected in perpetuity." It sold for $4,875,000 against $4,981,300 in transfers recorded October 29 to November 5. It had more than three times the land of any village-core lot on the list, permanently protected open space next door, and a house that was already among the island's more highly assessed. It still sold slightly under the town's number. The town's model had already valued the land and the house. What it leaves out is a short walk to the village center, and this house didn't have that.

3 Manatook Way was the largest sale in the group. In the same transfer week, it went for $8,625,000 against a $2,808,500 assessment, about three times the town's figure. The listing described a residence close to the village with a private pool, four bedrooms plus office space, a home gym and a wine cellar. Treat it as a single sale, not a benchmark for the area.

What the ratio tells you before you make an offer

If you're comparing 'Sconset with other neighborhoods, the assessment on a village listing is a 2024 baseline, and this fall the full houses in the core sold well above it. A list price far above the assessment there matches recent village sales. This fall, the sales that came in at or below the assessment were the smallest cottage, a house outside walking distance of the village, and a garage-and-gym building with an apartment above.

Some listings also carried things the town's model doesn't count. 76 Sankaty Road came with HDC-approved expansion and pool plans that conveyed with the sale, plus what the listing called "a strong summer rental history." The listing for 318 Milestone Road noted about 600 square feet of ground cover still available and an unfinished lower level with high ceilings and rough plumbing. 44 Sankaty Road was marketed with 2,000 square feet of ground cover available. On any 'Sconset house, ask for the room to grow and the approvals already in hand along with the assessment. You can see the island-wide view of how sales and transfer fees moved this year in our Land Bank ledger post, and current village listings are on our Sconset homes for sale page.

FAQ

Does a larger lot mean a higher price in 'Sconset? Not in this fall's sales. 10 Center Street on .03 acres sold 65% above its assessment. 318 Milestone Road, on more than fifteen times as much land, sold slightly below its assessment. Both were recorded in Nantucket Current roundups between September 17 and November 5, 2026.

Why do so many Nantucket homes sell above assessed value? The town's posted Fiscal Year 2026 values reflect the market as of January 1, 2025, built from 2024 sales, so a sale recorded in fall 2026 is measured against an older baseline. In 'Sconset, how far above it a house sells depends mostly on where it sits in relation to the village center.

Where can I follow 'Sconset sales as they record? Nantucket Current publishes a weekly real estate roundup with price, lot size and assessed value for each transfer. Our market insights page and Sconset neighborhood guide add context from the island side.

If you're weighing a village cottage on Cottage Avenue against a house out toward Sankaty Road, Amy and Henry at Sanford & Sanford will be glad to sit down with you and go through this fall's 'Sconset sales that fit the house you have in mind. Buy, Sell, or Rent with Sanford & Sanford.

Work With Us

We understand that your time is invaluable, and how you invest it is paramount. Choosing to spend your time on Nantucket Island can transform your lifestyle, and we are here to help you make the most of it. Whether you're exploring the charming Nantucket neighborhoods, enjoying Nantucket beach activities, or discovering the rich history of Nantucket, our experience and resources ensure you experience the best of Nantucket living. Let us help you embrace the unique lifestyle that Nantucket has to offer.

Follow Me on Instagram